During the 2025-26 season, Izabella Zingaro was arguably the best player in the Horizon League. As Cleveland State’s workhorse center, she averaged 16.9 points per game – making her the conference’s top scorer – and added 7.4 rebounds, helping the Vikings to 26 wins while grabbing all-league first team and Newcomer of the Year recognition from the HL.
Well before all of that, however, the Bolton, Ontario native began her college career at Iowa State. That period of her life abruptly re-entered the news on Friday, when she, Maggie Espenmiller-McGraw, and four additional, but anonymous, past Cyclones players submitted a formal complaint letter to the university, calling for an “independent, trauma-informed review of the program and its handling of player concerns.”
“We experienced or witnessed conduct we considered to be verbal, emotional, and psychological abuse from [ISU head coach Bill] Fennelly,” one portion of the letter read. “We reported this and what we believed was inappropriate physical contact to members of the coaching staff and Iowa State athletic administration, but we do not believe our concerns were taken seriously.”
“Our individual experiences may differ, but we are united in our concerns about an environment where intimidation, humiliation, and fear became normalized,” the letter continued. “We accepted the demands of hard work, discipline, and competitive excellence. But demanding excellence is fundamentally different from undermining an athlete’s dignity, wellbeing, and sense of safety.”
Zingaro played at Iowa State from 2020-23, and appeared in 44 games for the Cyclones (including, coincidentally, eight minutes of mop-up duty in the 2022-23 season opener against Cleveland State). She left the team after that year, and stepped away from basketball altogether in 2023-24, while completing her undergraduate degree.
Her most extensive public comments about that period came through a feature published on the University of Montana’s athletics website in October of 2024.
“It’s hard to tell what’s going on to someone from the outside,” she said. “It got to the point where I was at a long-time low and my mental health was not so great. The only way I was going to get better was to separate myself from the environment. I thought I’d push through another season, but that’s not what I needed. When you’re playing a sport that you’ve loved your whole life but you’re not having fun anymore, you know something’s wrong.”
“At the end of that first full season, something was not adding up for us,” Lorianna, Zingaro’s mother, added. “Speaking with other Canadian families, we knew it would be difficult and there were going to be ups and downs, but seeing what other Canadians were experiencing and the relationships they had with their coaches, I’m thinking, Izabella is not having any of that. Something is not right here.”
After plenty of reflection, Zingaro decided to give the game one last shot and found a friend who had experienced a very similar situation: Espenmiller-McGraw. Her former Iowa State teammate found Montana, and then-coach Brian Holsinger, to be an ideal recovery spot while completing her career during Zingaro’s hiatus season.
The rest of the story is a happy one, as the 6-4 center enjoyed a strong season in Big Sky country and then saved her best for CSU.
“I completely understood where she was coming from,” Espenmiller-McGraw said in the Montana feature. “We were on the same team for two and a half years, so we kind of experienced some of the same hardships together. That really bonded us over the years.”
In the letter, the six former Cyclones said that they “continue to deal with anxiety, depression, diminished self-worth, and lasting distress that we associate with our time in the program.”
The present backdrop of the complaint offers plenty of support. ISU has struggled with player retention in recent years – even when adjusting for the current climate in college basketball generally – and Fennelly was suspended for one game this past week, after pushing Cyclones guard Sienna Harvey’s head during a timeout on November 15th. Harvey later offered public support for her coach, however, the incident prompted Zingaro and the other former Iowa State players to come forward. They have also retained representation from Des Moines-based attorney Lori Bullock, but no legal action has been taken yet.
Fennelly became Iowa State’s coach since 1995, though he announced last month that he would retire at the end of this season. His accomplishments include 24 NCAA Tournament appearances and more than 650 wins with the Cyclones. He also, towards the beginning of his run at the school, gave former Cleveland State boss and ISU graduate Chris Kielsmeier his start in coaching.
Subscribe to our emails, and get our latest posts in your inbox, plus a weekly digest of everything we've published!




